|
![]() |
|
Thread Tools |
![]() |
#11 |
Iron Grenadier
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: Kansas
Posts: 699
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#12 |
Cobra Soldier
Join Date: Mar 2020
Location: Louisiana
Posts: 98
|
He's on Facebook. He has answered my DMs there before, but I doubt he would answer a direct question about the next publisher, if only because he's probably under an NDA while the next publisher works with Hasbro. As far as creators go, Larry Hama is generally accessible to fans.
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#13 |
Crimson Guard
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Boulder
Posts: 1,034
|
This is a great, well-researched post!
Thanks ScottyHawkeye. I enjoyed seeing the images and remembering where we'd been. This whole pitch gives me mixed feelings. As far as the other properties, I just don't know any of them very well and wouldn't spend any money on them at all. Especially not during this collapse time. I'm pretty much at the point of having a fire sale on all my 30+ years of comics, and selling off my Joe figures to feed my family. I suspect we'll see a lot more of that sentiment in the coming year. I guess I watched MASK a few times as a kid. I had the yellow motorcycle, the blue 57 Chevy, and a black Bronco. The toys were okay, they were cool for a season but I don't remember when I let them go and grew out of it. I barely remember the storyline. As a kid I was contemptuous of the Transformers. Hated them. I think I carried that sentiment into my teens and twenties, although now as an adult in my 40s I can appreciate the past Joe + Transformer comics way more than before. In fact, I always gave those a "pass," and rather enjoyed them, because they have generally been creative and "out of continuity." The best Joe + Transformers comic in my opinion was the Scioli one. That was epic. Next I would say is the Jae Lee art from the WW2 one. GiJoe was my first comic, and at this point one of my final comics. I'd like to think that in the future I'm still buying comics, but right now I'm down to about three. Strangers in Paradise / anything from Terry Moore, and Saga which I'm on the cusp of dropping. I've always collected mainstream and indy comics and most of my comic "career" (if you can call it that) was in indy comics. Often more soap opera-ish, slice of life, personal stuff a lot of the time. Although I do have boxes and boxes of mainstream comics as well. So from that angle I do think the GiJoe story needs a lot of interpersonal relationship stuff. It doesn't have to be soap opera, and I'm quite over the "main" characters at this point. The Scarlett and Mainframe relationship in IDW was great. Another missing aspect sometimes is just the basic friendship stories between the male Joes. Are there teammates who don't like each other? Are there guys who stick together through thick and thin? We see some of that with ARAH with Leatherneck, Outback, and Deep Six being unpopular. Or Clutch and Rock and Roll being bros. As far as your pitches, I'm totally in agreement about the idea of top talent doing side stories about individual characters, ala Deadgame. To me, there should be a little more alignment with the normal scope of the franchise, but out of continuity is okay if they must. (I think the only reason to even add that part is because of the goofiness of Deadgame). Also, the idea of an "Adventure Team" with a mixed cast of franchises sounds cool. All in the execution I suppose. (Do you think Adventure Force was a mix of the names Adventure Team and Action Force?) If there is only one Joe title, I'd be fine with that. I'm done with the ARAH storyline I think. The new publisher should mandate Larry to have ten issues to end all the plotlines and end the story (thus ending at 310 and doubling the 155 of the Marvel run). So the problem is, what story direction to go in after that? The best three alternate takes on GiJoe I would mention are Reloaded, IDW's first three years, and the Castle Fall continuity. The DDP continuation of ARAH was also great, in fact it was a better ARAH than Larry could write. I'm not sure if I count it as an alternate take since it was the main continuity. Costa's COBRA may be the cream of the crop but I think I includes it already as part of the IDW catch-all. I think the military realism needs to be part of the story. I also don't think it is wise to try to detach the team from being a primarily American team. Those would be some fences I would erect. Hasbro should also have some unity between core versions in different media to a greater degree. It seems like they intended that with Classified designs being in some games, but it doesn't seem to have stuck. I also really would push for developing the personalities of more obscure or fan favorite characters instead of the stale central figures we are used to. They're just not interesting. As far as art, I don't know what is right. My opinions on it don't seem to correlate with most of the Joe bros on here. I'm way more open to underground and indy art if it is quality, as long as the writing is not indy level. Mainstream comics readers aren't always GiJoe readers, and I'm not convinced that most GiJoe readers (us loyal 1,000 - 1,500 or so) are all necessarily readers of other comics. This is a tricky, super niche comic. Ultimately I'd like to see it appeal to more of the mainstream. I pitched a Dreadnoks comic to DT recently which I was serious about. There are so many rich characters and story possibilities which haven't even been discovered yet. I'd love to write it.
__________________
![]() 9/1/22 - A Day Which Will Live in Infamy Steevy Maximus - "that Nazi imagery was quaint" Last edited by J James; 01-18-2023 at 06:02 PM.. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#14 |
Iron Grenadier
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: Kansas
Posts: 699
|
Quote:
This is a great, well-researched post!
Thanks ScottyHawkeye. I enjoyed seeing the images and remembering where we'd been. This whole pitch gives me mixed feelings. As far as the other properties, I just don't know any of them very well and wouldn't spend any money on them at all. Especially not during this collapse time. I'm pretty much at the point of having a fire sale on all my 30+ years of comics and selling off my Joe figures to feed my family. I suspect we'll see a lot more of that sentiment in the coming year. I guess I watched MASK a few times as a kid. I had a yellow motorcycle, a blue 57 Chevy, and a black Bronco. The toys were okay, they were cool for a season but I don't remember when I let them go and grew out of it. I barely remember the storyline. Quote:
As a kid I was contemptuous of the Transformers. Hated them. I think I carried that sentiment into my teens and twenties, although now as an adult in my 40s I can appreciate the past Joe + Transformer comics way more than before. In fact, I always gave those a "pass," and rather enjoyed them, because they have generally been creative and "out of continuity."
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
So from that angle I do think the GiJoe story needs a lot of interpersonal relationship stuff. It doesn't have to be soap opera, and I'm quite over the "main" characters at this point. The Scarlett and Mainframe relationship in IDW was great. Another missing aspect sometimes is just the basic friendship stories between the male Joes. Are there teammates who don't like each other? Are there guys who stick together through thick and thin?
We see some of that with ARAH with Leatherneck, Outback, and Deep Six being unpopular. Or Clutch and Rock and Roll being bros. I would like more focus on the smaller name characters. I'm glad Blaylock had the Homecoming arc which gave more of a spotlight to Alpine, Mutt, Bazooka, and Rock & Roll instead of your usual Duke, Scarlett, Snake Eyes, and Roadblock. Quote:
As far as your pitches, I'm totally in agreement about the idea of top talent doing side stories about individual characters, ala Deadgame. To me, there should be a little more alignment with the normal scope of the franchise, but out of continuity is okay if they must. (I think the only reason to even add that part is because of the goofiness of Deadgame).
Quote:
![]() Quote:
If there is only one Joe title, I'd be fine with that. I'm done with the ARAH storyline I think. The new publisher should mandate Larry to have ten issues to end all the plotlines and end the story (thus ending at 310 and doubling the 155 of the Marvel run).
So the problem is, what story direction to go in after that? Quote:
The best three alternate takes on GiJoe I would mention are Reloaded, IDW's first three years, and the Castle Fall continuity. The DDP continuation of ARAH was also great, in fact, it was a better ARAH than Larry could write. I'm not sure if I count it as an alternate take since it was the main continuity. Costa's COBRA may be the cream of the crop but I think I include it already as part of the IDW catch-all.
![]() Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
As far as art, I don't know what is right. My opinions on it don't seem to correlate with most of the Joe bros on here. I'm way more open to underground and indy art if it is quality, as long as the writing is not indy level. Mainstream comics readers aren't always GiJoe readers, and I'm not convinced that most GiJoe readers (us loyal 1,000 - 1,500 or so) are all necessarily readers of other comics. This is a tricky, super-niche comic. Ultimately I'd like to see its appeal to more of the mainstream.
That's an interesting idea. Aside from Zartan, the Dreadnoks don't really get much of a spotlight Zander, Zarana, and Road Pig occasionally get their moments. I'd like to see Cesspool and Buzzer get a bigger spotlight. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#15 |
Just a fan
Join Date: Feb 2021
Location: NY
Posts: 6,553
|
It would be nice to have synergy between the toys and the comics.
__________________
4" Joes For Sale |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#16 |
Crimson Guard
Join Date: Nov 2013
Location: Boulder
Posts: 1,034
|
Yeah, I think that is really important to the brand.
Not indispensable, but important. Kids have different media today than we did though. I don't even know what that would look like today. Quote:
His writing is directed at teenagers mostly. I have many long boxes of his comics, lots of complete runs. He is a big social manipulator. I couldn't see that when I was younger. In a letters page in Saga he was sharing his desire to see people he didn't agree with be murdered on the large scale. Pretty sick. He left comics after successful runs on Y the Last Man, Runaways, Ex Machina and others. Actually I think I'm going to sell some of those as whole runs now that I think about it. He left comics and tried to break in to Hollywood. He was a replacement writer on "Lost" if that tells you anything. The Lost team was totally lost, it was a mess before he got there but he couldn't save it at all. Saga was his much-vaunted return to comics. I don't think he's written anything else noteworthy in the decade or so since that started. The whole comics industry is kinda capsizing because of stuff like Saga I think. I'm just stuck on it for no good reason, a completist. Maybe I oughta cancel it and buy something nice for my wife instead. If you want a long-form comic which is already complete, Cerebus is legendary! I love it. It is a funnier and way smarter comic. Saga is slow and really not smart. Cerebus ran to 300 issues, and was self-published the entire time. It is a masterpiece of discipline and an accomplishment. Also there is a new graphic novel called The Strange Death of Alex Raymond. It is amazing, and it is dense and slow to read. It's about the comics industry back in the 40s and is beautiful. I could recommend dozens of comic series lol. Quote:
In general, I'm tired of the soap opera nature of comics. Just make the character seem more natural and have natural interactions. I would like to see a focus on friendship angles. Duke is a huge part of why Flint was recruited into GI Joe because they knew each other in the military and wanted Flint to join the team. Also, Duke & Flint are from neighboring states and I think that should be given more attention. I know these are central characters and not some of the lesser-known characters who I agree need more of a spotlight too.
I would like more focus on the smaller name characters. I'm glad Blaylock had the Homecoming arc which gave more of a spotlight to Alpine, Mutt, Bazooka, and Rock & Roll instead of your usual Duke, Scarlett, Snake Eyes, and Roadblock. What I meant when I said that is character growth and interpersonal tension played out over long periods of time. I think a good comic series can keep plotlines and revelations going over a long period. Quote:
That's fair. I guess these kinds of miniseries don't have to be out of continuity. Snake Eyes Deadgame and Batman White Knight were just the first examples that came to mind for this concept. There are others like GI Joe COBRA & GI Joe COBRA II which were before the COBRA run. There were also Master & Apprentice miniseries. All of these were set in the respective continuities of an ongoing line.
Quote:
I literally was in a euphoria going to bed at night because GiJoe was back! And then I had an early morning opening shift and the day was dreadful. That terrorist tone in the comic changed pretty quickly. Quote:
Military realism is something I'm indifferent about. I like some more grounded comics and I also like my fair share of clones and androids in my GI Joe comics. I think there's a middle ground to having some comics that focus on military realism and others that feature more sci-fi-heavy elements.
I just want GiJoe to have realisitic, mission-oriented goals. The world they inhabit should continue to be weird. Make Voltar a real future tech threat! Oh, on THAT note. If all this exotic MARS technology is out there in the world, the civilian world ought to reflect that. There should be anti-grav vehicles in the background in cities. There should be robots on the street. GiJoe and Cobra have been fighting a long time. Some of this exotic stuff should be out there. Quote:
"Dreadnoks." Street-level vice. Nothing is taboo. Fentanyl, cocaine, meth smuggling. Human trafficking over the border. Prostitution. Gambling schemes. Arms deals? Maybe Voltar shows up for a story arc. Corrupt crypto fraud? A rep from Extensive Enterprises makes an appearance. The President's son needs a kilo of cocaine? Headman in the desert. Smuggling underage girls from South America for distribution into the government's internal sex trade? The Jugglers call in a favor and Cobra provides a security detail. The problem is so bad that a clandestine black books branch of the US military is trying to stop the madness at every level. Bulletproof, Law, Cutter, Chuckles, Mace, Leatherneck, Shockwave, and more street-level Joes are using force tactics to disrupt, but the Dreadnoks frequently win. Slaughter's Renegades are trying to infiltrate, but encounter resistance. And many of the military and government are aiding the Dreadnoks and facilitating their connections to various other bad actors, so the Jugglers play a part. Some of the Joes are not honest. The leader of the Dreadnoks keeps having moments of clarity and conscience, but his fellows keep dragging him back in. He continues to fight against his instincts and relishes the power.
__________________
![]() 9/1/22 - A Day Which Will Live in Infamy Steevy Maximus - "that Nazi imagery was quaint" |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#17 |
Cobra Viper
Join Date: Jul 2022
Location: Springfield
Posts: 177
|
My first step as a new publisher, would be to get rid of hama. I appreciate everything he's ever done for the brand and it wouldn't be what it is today without him...but he hasn't written a good gi joe story in the last five years other than a few issues of the untold tales. If he'd give us more stuff like that, I'd be all for him staying on, but more tham likely he'll continue the blue cyborg ninja stuff that should have ended at least a year ago
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#18 |
Cobra Viper
Join Date: Sep 2008
Location: Southern Cal
Posts: 275
|
THIS!
Human beings have a tendency to fall into a rut. Larry Hama is no different. Revanche, Brain Wave Scanner, and Cobra Commander + Dr. Mindbender ad nauseum... Larry worked best when he was FORCED to include new stuff. Hasbro: Larry, here is the crop of characters and vehicles we have releasing this year. Focus your story around this stuff. Larry: O.K. (Larry now forced to be extra creative to create a story given a set of characters). This provides fresh stories. Imagine what Hama could write if he were required to feature: 54-Bazooka-Tiger Force 55-Recondo-Tiger Force 58-Barbecue-Slaughter?s Marauders 59-Cover Girl 61-Kamakura 63-Outback 64-Falcon 57-Serpentor with Air Chariot 56-Cobra Officer-Python Patrol 66-Python Patrol Crimson Guard 60-Crimson B.A.T. Just looking at this list of characters, we could imagine a scenario: Deep in the jungles of Sierra Gordo, Recondo and Falcon lead a team (Cover Girl, Kamakura, Bazooka TF, Barbecue SM, and Outback) to investigate reports of a Cobra factory producing elite BATs for the Crimson Guard. To what end? Some fear that the Legion of the Nameless and Faceless is amassing once again. Will Serpentor return to lead them? And we get 6 months with no Duke, Scarlett, Dawn, or Snake-Eyes (although maybe in a flashback in Kamakura's memory). Last edited by Bryon; 01-19-2023 at 03:35 PM.. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#19 |
Iron Grenadier
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: Kansas
Posts: 699
|
|
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
#20 |
Iron Grenadier
Join Date: Apr 2022
Location: Kansas
Posts: 699
|
Quote:
I'd skip Saga if I were you. It is popular but not very good. It relies on shock value graphic imagery, one panel per issue. Guaranteed to have one revolting panel. Brian K Vaughan was one of my favorite comic writers at one time, but that was back in... probably the late 90s and early 2000s.
His writing is directed at teenagers mostly. I have many long boxes of his comics, lots of complete runs. He is a big social manipulator. I couldn't see that when I was younger. In a letters page in Saga, he was sharing his desire to see people he didn't agree with be murdered on the large scale. Pretty sick. He left comics after successful runs on Y the Last Man, Runaways, Ex Machina, and others. Actually, I think I'm going to sell some of those as whole runs now that I think about it. He left comics and tried to break into Hollywood. He was a replacement writer on "Lost" if that tells you anything. The Lost team was totally lost, it was a mess before he got there but he couldn't save it at all. Saga was his much-vaunted return to comics. I don't think he's written anything else noteworthy in the decade or so since that started. The whole comics industry is kinda capsizing because of stuff like Saga I think. I'm just stuck on it for no good reason, a completist. Maybe I oughta cancel it and buy something nice for my wife instead. If you want a long-form comic that is already complete, Cerebus is legendary! I love it. It is a funnier and way smarter comic. Saga is slow and really not smart. Cerebus ran to 300 issues and was self-published the entire time. It is a masterpiece of discipline and an accomplishment. Also, there is a new graphic novel called The Strange Death of Alex Raymond. It is amazing, and it is dense and slow to read. It's about the comics industry back in the 40s and is beautiful. I could recommend dozens of comic series lol. Quote:
I can agree with this. Probably "soap opera" is the wrong term. Strangers in Paradise is a soap opera.
What I meant when I said that is character growth and interpersonal tension played out over long periods of time. I think a good comic series can keep plotlines and revelations going over a long period. Quote:
Quote:
That's really cool. Thanks for sharing that. It was shocking when I read DDP #1 and Cobra Commander was an actual scary terrorist. Then the next day, the Twin Towers were hit.
I literally was in a euphoria going to bed at night because GiJoe was back! And then I had an early morning opening shift and the day was dreadful. That terrorist tone in the comic changed pretty quickly. Quote:
Clones and androids aren't even science fiction anymore. I don't mind some sci-fi aspects as long as they are handled well. Are the characters surprised by them, or has the tech been normalized? We live in a real-world that has human-animal chimera hybrids, driverless cars, robot dogs with human-hunting rifles mounted on their backs, brain implant wires to control thoughts from a central location, islands where wealthy elites fly to do evil away from moral eyes, nations being controlled through proxy dummy leaders, it's a weird world we live in.
I just want GiJoe to have realistic, mission-oriented goals. The world they inhabit should continue to be weird. Make Voltar a real future tech threat! Oh, on THAT note. If all this exotic MARS technology is out there in the world, the civilian world ought to reflect that. There should be anti-grav vehicles in the background in cities. There should be robots on the street. GiJoe and Cobra have been fighting for a long time. Some of this exotic stuff should be out there. ![]() I do agree with the idea of having mission-oriented goals and having the civilian world of the comic reflect those advances in technology. Maybe have civilian-like BATs do housekeeping in some homes instead of them only being canon fodder for COBRA. Quote:
This was my idea:
"Dreadnoks." Street-level vice. Nothing is taboo. Fentanyl, cocaine, meth smuggling. Human trafficking over the border. Prostitution. Gambling schemes. Arms deals? Maybe Voltar shows up for a story arc. Corrupt crypto fraud? A rep from Extensive Enterprises makes an appearance. Does the President's son need a kilo of cocaine? Headman in the desert. Smuggling underage girls from South America for distribution into the government's internal sex trade? The Jugglers call in a favor and Cobra provides a security detail. The problem is so bad that a clandestine black books branch of the US military is trying to stop the madness at every level. Bulletproof, Law, Cutter, Chuckles, Mace, Leatherneck, Shockwave, and more street-level Joes are using force tactics to disrupt, but the Dreadnoks frequently win. Slaughter's Renegades are trying to infiltrate, but encounter resistance. And many of the military and government are aiding the Dreadnoks and facilitating their connections to various other bad actors, so the Jugglers play a part. Some of the Joes are not honest. The leader of the Dreadnoks keeps having moments of clarity and conscience, but his fellows keep dragging him back in. He continues to fight against his instincts and relishes power. |
![]() |
![]() |
![]() |
Thread Tools | |
![]() |
||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
New Publisher Comics Predictions | Dreadnok Twins | IDW G.I. Joe Comics Readers Club | 57 | Yesterday 01:16 PM |
Vintage Transformers Lunchbox, WWF VHS, Micheal Myers Mask, EbAY | SportsandStuff | G.I. Joe Buy Sell Trade | 0 | 10-28-2019 03:57 PM |
gi joe vs transformers comics??? | CVdelgado | Comic Books Discussion | 19 | 07-21-2010 11:29 AM |
MASK comics for sale | neurocamerman | G.I. Joe Buy Sell Trade | 3 | 08-20-2009 08:39 AM |
Star Trek, Transformers and MASK DVDs | nighthawk | G.I. Joe Buy Sell Trade | 2 | 10-08-2008 11:56 AM |
|
|
Recent Off Topic Threads |
G.I. Joe Classified March Madness Round 2 Road Pig vs... |
4" Fortnite from Jazwares |
Hisstank Late Night thread... |
Best Thing to Happen at a Con |
What song are you listening to? |